Théophile Gautier is full of praise either: “this entire composition is collected and concentrated with extreme happiness, presenting on all sides lines of harmonious grace. M. Debay handled the brush before touching the chisel; we guess it from a picturesque feeling that sculptors do not usually have”. The group is worth to its author a medal. Exhibited again at the Universal Exhibition of 1855 (No. 4314), it was purchased by one of the greatest collectors of the time, Prince Anatole Demidoff. It soon adorned his Tuscan palace in San Donato, before being sold with the rest of the collections on March 15, 1880 (lot 135). Now disappeared, the work is only known thanks to the few workshop plasters which have survived, then to the posthumous reprints which were executed.
Indeed, in addition to the marble exhibited at the Salon, Debay kept the plaster that served as his model, and a few others, which he intended for institutions to promote his work or for his relatives as a testimony of friendship.
Thus we know:
The success of Le Berceau primitive did not end with the death of Debay, quite the contrary. The posthumous casts of Barbedienne and the plasters bearing the stamp "Salvator Marchi, MD et Editeurs de Me Pradier, Bapts" constitute the major part of the prints but are not originals. Our sculpture is one of the rare original copies still in private hands. It allows you to rediscover one of the heights of romanticism in sculpture.
This original vision of the artist of the first maternal tenderness, this choice to represent, not the drama of the first fratricide but the innocence of the first age marked much the contemporaries of Debay. The different levels of reading, the beauty of Eve which is reminiscent of the sweetness of Michelangelo's Madonnas, the rich symbolism of this group also explain its success. Debay, son of a sculptor and author at the age of 13 of a first royal bust, then embarked on a career as a painter thanks to his master Baron Gros. With The First Cradle, he definitively places his name among the great sculptors of the 19th century.